I think this is not new for some users who read or edit on other wikis that they hold their discussions about requesting user rights in their general discussion board on forums. However, instead of keeping it tying with other discussions on that board, I propose we create a new board, namely, "User Rights Requests." Here, we can make our free discussions on whether the user is eligible to gain the right, or have it lapsed of him/her. For this new system, we delete the old syntax of requests, and implement a new one on the board:
- The title of each request on discussions should be: "Proposal: (the right's name) Rights for (the name of the user)"
Those who support, must use the {{Support}} template and give their reason (if they want). Those who oppose, must use the {{Oppose}} template and give their reason (if they want). Or use the {{Neutral}} template and discuss your problem with those who want the right.Anyone can "support, Oppose and be Neutral" in the the way they want, although their opinion must be clear so that admins and bureaucrats can understand.
This new system differs in that requests can be highlighted there and give every user the free to comment just like any normal discussion, unlike our old article-like portal that feels somewhat unsorted and too formal that users may be afraid to cast their votes there.
Other than the change in syntax, bureaucrats or even admins have to just summerize the number of supporters, opposers and neutrals on their comments at the end of the request's time. These requests must always be highlighted by admins, and should immediately be moved to closed site discussions after the time of the request has reached its end.
P.S. There is no need for signatures here. And other than what I mentioned above, the polices for requests are the same.