Board Thread:Site Discussions/@comment-2054358-20150221164611/@comment-679780-20150221185002


 * oppose:

1. It's not Sonic- and thats precisely the good point to start off with. We're a Sonic wiki and our information relates to Sonic one way or another. Mario has more history with Sonic than any other fighter in the game series, pitting Sonic against them does not count as legitimate interaction.

2. Sonic isn't a main character- Super Mario is the posterboy of the Super Smash Brothers along with the majority of fighters hailing from the Super Mario series. Plus while he is regarded as a "veteran", chances are Nintendo decided to keep him just to profit from Sonic fans wanting to fight as Sonic. The point I am making is just because there is no singular main character in a fighting game doesn't mean they are all main characters. Plus Sonic has the least apperance in commercialism around Brawl and 4. when it comes to percentage, Mario and Sonic Olympic games are more 50-50 with Sonic while Sonic only takes up a small portion of Super Smash Bros.

3. We'd be another Smash Wiki- My main concern is that for a Sonic wiki we'd give too much article attention to Nintendo characters who don't really need it. Not to mention there will be more third-party Nintendo character articles than we have third-party sega characters, some of which have had history with Sonic. It look kinda ridiculous if Nintendo out-populates Sega here.

4. Smash 4 wasn't released yet- It has now, yeah.

5. Smash doesn't count- It only counts as a spin-off game. articles about spin-off games are approved as well as articles on it's Sonic related contents, but we don't have to expulge all the non-Sonic content along with it.

6. More admins and experienced users voted delete- So as an admin my oppinions to promote more sega based articles over Nintendo on a Sonic wiki is overruled? Well, I do support an alternative which I think would be best.

With all the Super Smash articles you made, why can't you put them all onto one single article? If anything this way the article will be more directly related to Sonic than they would be seperately because as playable fighters they all are optionally interactible with Sonic.