Board Thread:Speculation, Theories, and Rumors./@comment-15024974-20140711031830/@comment-679780-20140718075443

Whitestormr wrote: Mystic Monkey wrote:

Whitestormr wrote:

Sonicyoaifangirl1904 wrote: Whitestormr wrote: Sonicyoaifangirl1904 wrote: Whitestormr wrote: Sonicyoaifangirl1904 wrote: Myself 123 wrote: "1:13, Espio knows him. 1:16 Charmy just being an airhead, or confirmed Whovian."

MM was pointing out how Espio knows who Eggman is. Well, of course he knows who Eggman is! The guy blew the moon in half! You were saying earlier that none of them recognized Eggman, you are contradicting yourself. What I meant is that they never actually met him. but they probably have some idea of who he is. Well... Canon or not, Knuckles Chaotix is unimportant. (I am aware I'm the one who brought it up) It's definitely one of the least heard of and least accessible games. Hav any of us here discussing it even played it? I haven't. Right... But if for some reason anyone still wonders if Knuckles Chaotix is canon, I think this is a deal breaker http://sonicworld.sonicretro.org/angel_island_interviews/interviews/2004/sonic_2004_feb_03.htm Yes! Thank you, that definitely closes this whole Chaotix thing up. I still don't think that the interview confirms or denies that Knuckles Chaotix as non canon. Just the director Takashi Iizuka says that they weren't involved with Knuckles Chaotix; some other internal sega Development team did that. That means that it is still a Sonic game licenced by Sega and thus could still be ringed into Sonic lore. I think what Iizuka did was simply revamp them for modern era. There past can still be canon to them just as Classic Sonic is considered Modern Sonic's childhood in Sonic Generations. I'm sorry but I think Sonicyoaifangirl1904 has conclusive evidence. Knuckles Chaotix is not canon. I don't think the evidence is conclusive enough. She could be right but it's not a solid yes or no. I believe Knuckles Chaotix is an outdated spin-off from Sonic lore but like all spin-offs that doesn't mean it still not part of it one way or another. All in all there is evidence on both our cases but not enough to confirm or deny the canon of the old game. I think the best way to get a direct answer from Sonic Team themselves than just saying "We based it after the original".