Board Thread:Speculation, Theories, and Rumors/@comment-679780-20160710203708/@comment-679780-20160710233340

I think Scourge was concentrating on Sega's Silver the Hedgehog while GamerGuyd7Aces used the Archie comics for his examples which I'm against. I prefer Scourges methods and think his theories are sound.

The only thing I am against about his theory is that he doesn't take into account all other possible contributors to Silvers family tree other than Sonic and Amy. After all if Sonic and Amy were to have a child who is the ancestor of Silver then what about that childs future spouse? What if Silver inherited traits mostly from said spouse than Sonic or Amy's bloodline? Sure we can accept some traits would be passed down but that could be merely apperance than anything more powerful.

For all we know for Shadow who is immortal, he or any of his decendants my end up a branch in Silvers tree eventually. If even confirmed in Flame Core located in Silvers Future he is still alive but in imprisoned stasis which is evident of his immortality.

While I prefe rSilvers ancestory to be left ambigous, it is possible decendants of Sonic, Amy or Shadow may have mixed with Silvers ancestry.