User blog comment:Mystic Monkey/Sonic Creepypasta/@comment-477304-20130408214001/@comment-477304-20130408220442

I found the Tails Doll creepy when I first came across it in Sonic R. But all the Tails Doll horror stories have softened the horror, the Tails Doll curse thing is basically a meme now, so it can't be used in a good Sonic creepypasta. I agree that a Sonic creepypasta shouldn't have to include non-sonic stuff.

I think a good creepypasta would have to start out slowly and subtley better getting worse and worse, and there has to be some rythme or reason to it, as opposed to the same thing happening over and over again.