Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-15588403-20140429194622/@comment-25839693-20141209174300

CleverFox101 wrote:

Silvaze Fangirl wrote: I don't support either couples. ShadAmy makes no sense, there's no way Amy would lose her feelings for Sonic and move on with Shadow. Although this could work in fan fiction, but not in the games (Sega will probably still show Amy going after Sonic). And SonAmy is also unlikely because Sonic clearly does not have feelings for her. What I've said is not intended to make anyone upset. I respect SonAmy and ShadAmy fans. No No your fine. Opinions are welcome. For that I half agree and half disagree. SonAmy would never work in the games, because yes Sonic's character does and probably will never have feelings For Amy. But with ShadAmy, No Amy would not immediately move on to Shadow, But Amy like everyone, has to move on from there crushes. But in a sense Shadow and Amy would make much sense.

In the Games Amy is Shadow's Voice of Reason for Shadows Purpose. (I could go on about this but ill cut it short an simple) Think of them like Yin and Yang. Amy is like the light in Shadows Darkness. In the games (if Shadamy was ever cannon) the sense is that Amy can repair Shadows broken heart.

Its a corny statement to make but its true. Maria WAS his purpose for being, Amy IS (now) his purpose for being, whom he is. I'm not intending to flame here but there's a sentences (in bold) here that I kinda don't agree with. It's true that Amy must move on from crushes, these things are normal. But in fiction, well, often natural things in real life may not apply in fiction. I have some examples:


 * The Disney version of Robin Hood established Robin and Marian knowing each other since childhood, after many years they reunited with each other and got married. In real life, only a few people end up marrying their first love, others may end up having a number of romances and marrying their recent love.
 * In the Simpsons episode "Guess Who's Coming To Criticize Dinner?" where Homer got a job as a food critic, his reviews eventually lead to several restaurant owners teaming up to poison him with a eclair. When Homer and his family arrive at the fair, a bat randomly flies in and bites Homer on his neck. I read that it is dangerous to get bitten by bats as they are a large cause for Rabies, and since the show is set in the US (which is unfortunately not safe from Rabies), Homer could of been inflected and rushed to the hospital. Although like I said, things in real life may not happen in fiction. And anyway Homer may of been vaccinated in the past, so I think we can assume he is safe from contacting rabies.

Back on topic now, I now agree with you on ShadAmy making sense. And the voice of reason thing, was only in Sonic Adventure 2 as far as I'm aware. And I know what you mean on the rest of the sentences you wrote (After the highlighted sentence). But in my opinion, Amy doesn't look like the type of person who'll give up on pursuing Sonic, but there's always fan fiction.