Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24074103-20131204160455/@comment-26569191-20140729173048

@MysticMonkey

I think I was like you once upon a time. Anyways I'm not now, so I'll be the one to tell you that you're reaching. Hard.

"If you persist to use Meteor Crush as your reason, well in the Skill Information it never states those rocks come from space nor that Knuckles have complete control of the "supernatural power of the earth". Just that he makes it happen which could be by any reason. He perhaps have telepathy to the Master Emerald to ask it to drop a few rocks. It is also important to remember that Sonic Battle is considered a spin-off game so it is questionable of how much it holds to the main series."

You are thinking way too hard deeply about this and in the process you're screwing up your own train of thought and reasoning.

"If you persist to use Meteor Crush as your reason, well in the Skill Information it never states those rocks come from space"

No one said that but you. In fact no one BUT you even brought that up that up in some benefit to their argument. You did in an effort to to give some leverage as to continue on with their point, but now you're denying that they're from space at all.

"nor that Knuckles have complete control of the "supernatural power of the earth". Just that he makes it happen which could be by any reason. "

..Lord Jesus, I don't even know where to start with this. Common sense tells you that the sentence as it is means one thing. You don't have to work hard to analyze and tear apart basic English in this manner.

"He perhaps have telepathy to the Master Emerald to ask it to drop a few rocks."

No. It told you he does it "through supernatural control of the earth". Now I don't care where you think the rocks came from, but THIS much is obvious. He didn't have to ask the Master Emerald to drop anything. That's not "through supernatural control of the earth". That's he had to go out of his way to ask the master emerald soemthing. People know how to write in English. Like I said, this is reaching.

"It is also important to remember that Sonic Battle is considered a spin-off game so it is questionable of how much it holds to the main series."

Okay, first thing. If you're trying to make a point about something, you don't disregard the entire thing especially, where it's coming from, unless you've lost your point and have found that it is entirely faulty. Second, if you've been in the Sonic community for more than a few months, you should know that whether or not it's a spin off has no bearing on any of this. In fact, even if you didn't know that, you could have at least known that spin-offs are included in the chronicling of events in history. Especially a game like Sonic Battle.

"It also states that Amy Heal works by Amy thinking purely about Sonic. By that logic she should be ÜberCharged 24/7."

Okay seriously? You're comparing a mechanic of Amy to the mechanic of Knuckle's Meteor Crush? Have you never seen that skills used by characters in games (yes even in Sonic games) differ in both explanation, origin, direction, inspiration and even connection to canon? For example in the Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm Series. Is the "Hokage Mode" for Minato legit? No. Does that mean that the "One Tailed cloak mode" for Naruto isn't? This should be kindof really elementary stuff here. I think that the fact that you are thinking too much about this is the reason that you a.) aren't really getting it and are b.) running into the comments that you are.