User blog comment:ShavicShadic12/Shadow vs Silver/@comment-153.107.97.151-20120528031532

it's a matter of brains versus brawn I think, and that makes Silver the winner. He can easily just stop Shadow in his tracks. Shadow on the other hand is the ultimate lifeform and stuff but Sonic beats him heaps and Silver pretty much owned Sonic in Sonic '06 so I think that it'd be pretty tight, but Silver would probably pull off the win.