Board Thread:Speculation, Theories, and Rumors/@comment-26186871-20150519145945/@comment-679780-20150528021419

TheFreddyFromThePizzaria wrote: What about the classic sonic games? Sonic 1, 2, CD, 3, and knuckles? The SUPER emeralds there look like the modern chaos emeralds. Not only that, but none of these sonic games have any cities. Are these yet another earth?

And so heh, good explanation, it's not the Earth we live on, but a DIFFERENT Earth.. heh..

Wait, if Möbius is a parallel Earth by your logic, that means Zelda, Equestria, and pretty much ANY world could potentially be an "alternate earth" Our earth has NO chaos emerald-like objects or even super forms.. Magic is not found in our version of earth like in Möbius and Equestria, and animals definetly don't speak on Earth. The only things that Möbius have in common with Earth is the fact that there's life on them, they are ocean-land planets, it is at a one-star system, has one moon, and there is at least one human there. Other than that, they have NOTHING in common that we know of. Our planet has no Chaos, no super form, no animal civilization, no GOING AROUND AT THE SPEED OF SOUND, nothing to balance chaos with non-chaos, no having just ONE human remain, gems are a lot less common here, gold is worth a lot more here, thus rarer here, and there is no time-travel. (By "Earth" in these sentences, I mean THIS Earth. The one we, the PEOPLE, live on.)

Equestria has more similarities to möbius than möbius does to OUR Earth. When I said Möbius was not Earth, I said Möbius was not OUR Earth. So if Möbius can be a parallel Earth, then Equestria can at least be a parallel Earth.

As for your paragraphs, I spotted a contradiction. You say that Earth split into two timelines at a certain point, right? The time of awakening? You also say that the chaos emeralds were always around.. Shouldn't this mean that there WOULD be chaos emeralds here? After all, they were there before the Time of Awakening, so in this scenario, they should still exist here to this DAY. The classic games just as count as the modern game. I believe that the Chaos Emeralds were originally Old Single Cut in shape or very least Emerald Cut, Square. When the Chaos Emerald became the Super Emeralds they transformed in size becoming as large as Sonic and friends as well as shape becoming Diamond Cut. when the hyper Emeralds returned to being Chaos Emeralds they shrank back down to normal size but retained their modern Diamond Cut shape.

Also the classic Sonic games did have cities, such as Spring Yard Zone, Star Light Zone, the background of Scrap Brain Zone and also Chemical Plant Zone, Casino Night Zone and I guess Metropolis Zone sorta counts a sa city even if the population is mostly robots.

And my alternate Earth theory can still hold water since I point out that at one point both Sonic's world and our Earth shared the same timeline. It is just our planet never had Gaia to initiate Time of Awakenings. And yes, any world could potentially be an alternate Earth but it really depends at what point in history does the unique world stem from our planets history.

For example a more common My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic theory is that Equestria will happen in our distant future someday, such theories as an artificial sun, scientist create a breed of pony with a matriarch queen pony that can control the sun while humans die out and leave ponies to inherit the earth.

Your example of Hyrule being set on Earth at any point of history however seems unlikely as the golden goddesses are said to be behind Hyrule's world creation story, unless the whole universe of Hyrule is unique and that the planet of Hyrule is this universes equivilent of Earth which can be just as likely.

You pointing out clear differences between Sonic's world and Earth, I thought I clearly explained this clearly in my previous post. Did you actually read all of it?

Our Earth never had Time of Awakening While Sonic's world did! It is the Time of Awakening followed by millions and millions of years, especially more Time of Awakenings that causes Sonic's world to be different from ours. The constant destruction and assemble of Sonic's Earth has caused plenty of geological changes and evolutional shifts in the world that causes Sonic's world to be different from ours. Also those who were aware of Gaia have created the Gaia Temples, these temples were made tens of thousands of years a go! This is an important fact because Pachacamac's echidnas existed as far as Four thousand years a go, this means the Chaos Emeralds existed long before the echidnas! The Pachacamac's echidnas did not create the Chaos Emeralds, merely named them after the God of Destruction.

Another thing which you seem to have missed out entirely, you think Sonic's world consist of one human and no cities. Have you actually played any Sonic games for the Dreamcast and up? Have you actually played Sonic Unleashed to know more about the cultures and people of Sonic's world? Sonic's world has loads in common with our world. They're not identical twins but my theory is that our planet was not fertilized with Gaia to begin with.

Lastly, while I did say the Chaos Emeralds were as old as time itself, I meant that figuratively, as in as old as time of Earth. The Gaia Temples were constructed in order to restore the planet after Time of Awakening in which the Chaos Emeralds were needed to use them, so the Chaos Emeralds were created around the first or perhaps a later Time of Awakening when life began to advance. Because our planet never had Gaia or Time of Awakening means no need or happenstance of the creation of the Chaos Emeralds.