Board Thread:Speculation, Theories, and Rumors/@comment-679780-20150901194232/@comment-679780-20151016001613

Observer Supreme wrote: I actually find Chronicles to be canonical to the games that take place on an alternate Earth. So what if the maps were a little screwy? It doesn't matter to me much. Besides, as far as I know, Penders is the one who keeps messing up with his petty royalties or whatever they're called. And while I understand the preferences for Archie to have made an independent Sonic, one could argue that there were a good amount of flaws regardless of the time they were made in. An alternate Earth I can udnerstand, but can't say same Earth or canon to the major Sonic games.

As a long-time Sonic fan, it irks me whenever Green HIll Zone is not part of South Island. I know the old canon is dated, even by Sega's standards, but it still bothers me.