User blog comment:Pikatwig/Most Burning Way Past Cool Sonic games and my reasons/@comment-1986314-20120127114040

While the Generations game was good on both consoles, I have to disagree with you on placing them first. Sure, they contained many cool stages and it was a nostalgia overload, but my top favorites would have to be Sonic 3 and Knuckles in 2nd, and Sonic Adventure DX: Directors Cut in first.

As for the others, I agree and disagree with a few, but I won't go into details. Fairly good list you have here.