Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24145744-20140321205722/@comment-26808654-20140503023442

Damastermind wrote: Evtini200 wrote:

Damastermind wrote:

Evtini200 wrote: I don't think so. Classic Sonic was removed from  time before the time eater went for MS. If they were the same timeline, MS would have cease to exist. Not to mention, CS has about as much dialogue as Chell, whereas CT can talk. CS was never removed from time. CS might have just prefered not to talk until sometime in Sonic CD. After all, that's supposedly why Chell didn't talk. Actually he was removed from time, along with the other characters and stages. Chell never spoke because 1. No one to talk to and 2. Saying anything would bring her closer to insanity. CS had a lot of people he could have (and probably should have) talked to without it affecting his mental status. Another point, Eggman said he needed help to master the Time Eater yet he still managed to go back in time. My theory is since he couldn't control it, he went to the wrong timeline.

@Mike. Chell is the protagonist of the Portal series. She talks even less than Classic Sonic. Well, Valve DID say that she probably just didn't prefer to talk. And he was NEVER removed from time.

The time eater romeved them all from time. That White Space they were in? It exists beyond time and space. It's a place where nothing exists. When the Time Eater brought them there, they were removed from time. The only things in White Space were the things the Time Eater brought with him while traveling through time. So when Time Eater brought CS to White Space, CS was removed from time. Keep in mind, this happened before Time Eater went for MS. If those two were from the same timeline, MS would have cease to exist. Not to mention, the Time Eater has shown that he's capable of traveling through multiple timelines. He was able to reach Crisis City, an area from a seperate timeline that no long exists. So yeah, seperate timelines.