Sonic News Network talk:Community Portal

This page is for ongoing discussions relating to the whole of Sonic News Network.

Older, closed discussion can be found at Sonic News Network talk:Community Portal/Closed.

Confusing portal
Normally the community portal article is kinda meant for project link to guidelines, news, etc, etc... And the discussion page for things related to the article. This wikia has done things... Different. O_o One-Winged Hawk 10:57, September 27, 2009 (UTC)


 * I am currently working on this. -- Supermorff 18:16, March 26, 2010 (UTC)

Trivia
This wikia is in desperate need of trivia guidelines, its the biggest single let down I find and from the Silver page some suggestions:
 * 1) At the most no trivia section should have more then 12 points of trivia, anymore and you have to ask what is and isn't truly trivia.
 * 2) If theres a chuck of related trivia, give it its own section elsewhere on the page.
 * 3) A trivia section should NEVER have more text in it then any other seciton of the page.
 * 4) Don't trivia for the sake of trivia.  This is considered unprofessional, sloppy and desperate. In other words, don't point out the obivous (i.e. for examples sake: "collecting Rings will give you Rings")
 * 5) Don't let speculations in there, we could speculate all day on if character like Silver and Shade are going to appear in the future.
 * 6) Cut out the character comparisons between Sonic and Shadow and Sonic and Silver and Silver and Blaze, etc. They are long, boring and useless. Any set amount of characters within a series will share traits with each other, there is little sense in pointing them out.
 * 7) Keep mention of fan out of the page. Magazines, yeah heck include them.  Fan don't.
 * 8) "Most", "Many" and "Some" are poor words and should be avoided anyway on the page. How many is many?  What percentage is Most?  Same with Some.  Many could be several, several hundred or sevenral thousand.

Thats all that I can think of. The other sections on any wikia are easy to clean up, but trivia is the one thing that needs to be controlled carefully. Wikipedia has this whole "anti-trivia" thing on it, wikias are the only haven trivia has. One-Winged Hawk 10:57, September 27, 2009 (UTC)


 * That's exactly what I'm thinking. I've been trying to edit the article's trivia sections and cleaning them up but they kept being brought back. What's worse is that it was a moderator that did it. Apparently it's not just editors but if a mod thinks it's okay, then no one in this wiki knows how to properly do trivia correctly. The points you have made are exactly what I have in mind sans the first one. There is no specific number for trivia, it's just what you can fit in the article that is necessary. Even if there are 20 items that can't be placed in the article itself, then it could still be counted as trivia but of course it's gotta be a correct definition of Trivia.--TKGB 00:37, October 8, 2009 (UTC)


 * I agree with you on all points, although am willing to compromise slightly on the character comparisons. Shadow, Blaze and (to a lesser extent) Silver were all designed with the intention of being counterparts to Sonic. This may be worth mentioning, although the long lists of pointless trivia we get regarding these (e.g. "they both have 5 letters in their name") should be cut. -- Supermorff 17:20, September 30, 2009 (UTC)

Over-categorisation is not the answer, although I would not be opposed to list articles to serve the same purpose. -- Supermorff 21:42, October 1, 2009 (UTC)