Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27033632-20160215163310/@comment-24658561-20160220135036

Depends on the incarnations. Judging from the more recent games Shadow is definitely going to win because they turned Knuckles into a f*cking idiot who gets pushed around by the girls for comedy, but for the comic incarnation I wouldn't be so sure. It also depends on the environment. If the battle took place on some kind of plain environment with little obstacles, Shadow could take full advantage of his speed and Chaos Spear would be pretty hard to avoid. Now if it was a cave or water environment, Knuckles would have an advantage since he can move underground and is said to be a very good swimmer.