Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27056607-20151008232518/@comment-679780-20151012234834

Kroshy wrote: Honestly I don't think Sonic is in love with her at all, at least not in the games. He never shows her ANY kind of affection besides caring if she is in danger or not, but that pretty much counts for anybody, even eggman himself. Hell they never even really talk to each other, shadow has better chemistry with sonic. Elise seemed to be the closest thing to love I have ever seen. I believe that Sonic could love her if he was comfortable to do so in his own pace. But because Amy appears so needy for him this down-rights puts him off. He still cares for Amy but for now would just rather be her friend. I do believe he does have genuine feelings for Amy but prefers to keep them to himself given there are qualities of Amy he is repulsed by, such as her desires of marriage. Perhaps given a few years both will be mature enough to have a stable relationship. But while Sonic has been a hero for 25 years, Sega will always have him 15 and Amy 12.

As for SonElise, I believe the romance is one-sided. Yes Elise fell in love with Sonic, it became evident, but Sonic's behavior towards her seems more platonic to me, his devotion was that of saving her as a hero and that of a good friend. Sonic could of been sceptible to her feelings but chose not to recuperate because he did not feel mutural with her, or simply was not threatened by her interest as he felt with Amy. That or did not want her to have hopes in a hedgehog who is like the wind and must leave someday.

Eitherway I choose Amy when it comes to the Test of Love.