Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25109438-20140609135947/@comment-26534989-20150716204911

Sonicboom14 wrote: I have been comparing Amy Rose to Amy Rose (Sonic Boom) and the comparison is drastic (Besides her always trying to get Sonic to date her and the Piko Piko Hammer). For instance, Amy from Sonic Boom is more acrobatic, more faster, more skilled and overall better than the annoying hotheaded little girl who almost always needs Sonic to rescue her from Eggman. Plus, Amy actually has a chance against Eggman in Sonic Boom and I would doubt that Amy would survive to minutes in the ring with Eggman. So, I guess you would know where I stand on this: I prefer Amy Rose from Sonic Boom than Amy Rose from the video games. Your opinion  on the Amy Roses. I really dislike Boom!Amy.

Okay, she's more acrobatic. Faster ? Nope, I don't think so - I think she remain inchanged, or she is even slower. And you think she's better ? Because what, her crush was removed and..?

Okay, this Amy is supposed to be motherly, sweet and kind. No problem with that. But instead we got an hypocritical (she was the first to yell at Tails when he made a single mistake, and then shows worry about random kids she doesn't even know and fall TWICE in the same trap - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcyhpRFv1C8), a girl that sometimes treat people like shit and act like she's superior to others (https://youtu.be/Bdv2qScQUhA, https://youtu.be/G9vgyiw2QHU, http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v190/Shadowluna15/D7AFFBC6-5177-44E2-A2BF-AB4A3531B4CB-218-0000001FEE1BECAD_zps0c401d4b.jpg, http://40.media.tumblr.com/f95feadf9d20bfca69512d45dea30e84/tumblr_nelnko91U21s1uqd4o1_1280.jpg, http://41.media.tumblr.com/102f98f8e0dc7475f2179c6ed1ea0335/tumblr_ne8i5iYuc91rxenr3o2_1280.jpg, http://41.media.tumblr.com/fff5131ef357bc0a3dde308313024e81/tumblr_ng2j13fEdI1qlj42ao1_1280.jpg). She's often the one who leaves the team (https://youtu.be/UCYjAyX-V60) and honestly ? Except when she was captured by Eggman, the others didn't care that much and were just enjoying their day without her (it's especially obvious in the restaurant episode, and even with the first few minutes in the Chili-Dog episode). In those episodes she was sad, of course, and just after she's okay with it and team with someone else (aka Eggman). Yet she remembers that she has friends only when she's in trouble. Yeah great.

Ah yes, this episode (https://youtu.be/UCYjAyX-V60). So she can beat Eggman ? Not at all. She's just fucking waiting to someone to help her and she doesn't even try to get out by herself. At least, SEGA!Amy actually tries something and sometimes she get out by herself (Sonic Adventure 1 is the best example.)

Oh, and I don't care at all for SonAmy.

Of course Boom!Amy is sometimes a good character... But this ? No, I can't. Even if SEGA!Amy's crush for Sonic has flanderized her character and make her annoying sometimes, she wasn't THAT horrible to other people, even when she was angry / jealous.