Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-4383275-20150414221305/@comment-4383275-20150620191841

Wolf Fang Liberator Garmore wrote: Wait no it is.

Elise didn't blow out the candle because Eggman undid his defeats. Therefore, '06 is canon and everything there did happen.

I can easily back this up because Metal Sonic wakes up in the Bad Future. But didn't Sonic reinstate Eggman's defeats by destroying the Time Eater? After all, once the Time Eater was defeated, all the past areas that were trapped in the White Space disappeared and were returned to their respective places in the timeline. Besides, if Sonic '06 and the Bad Future of Stardust Speedway in Sonic CD were both canon, wouldn't that retcon the good ending of Sonic CD?