Talk:Amy Rose/Archive 1

Made a minor edit on December 29th in enemy section. Removed Princess Peach since she has almost nothing to do with the series and only appears in the olympic games.

"Taila"???
Someone put "Amy's middle name is "Talia". Did some dude make this up??? And what proof is there that that's her real middle name? Of all the Sonic games I know there has been NO PROOF that she even has a middle name! --Sonicrox14 02:32, 4 April 2009 (UTC)Sonicrox14


 * I think you're right. Seems like a fan thing. Could possibly be from a non-games continuity.
 * Where does it mention that in the article? -- Supermorff 07:45, 4 April 2009 (UTC)

It had said so in Trivia. It's gone now, someone must've deleted it. It could just be true only in the comics, now that I think about it... --Sonicrox14 02:27, 5 May 2009 (UTC) Shelly the  Hedgehog 

Comparing other Media

 * the Trivia section here feels like a mess. First there's comparisons to Naruto, now Thomas the tank engine. Do any of these things matter. Amy has a very stereotypical female anime personality and can probably be compared to a hundred characters from other shows, comics, games, etc. I say we get rid of all this comparison non-sense. Sonictoast 15:17, 31 July 2009 (UTC)


 * Very true. Removed. -- Supermorff 16:49, 31 July 2009 (UTC)

Uhn?
In the trivia:

"Amy's name might actually be referring to her nature as Sonic's love interest, since the name 'Amy' means 'love' and a rose is a common symbol of love."

In French Amy means "beloved" but that is so not the reason for Amy's name. During that time Amy was a common name like "Sally" (hence Sally Acorn) so they hought it would do. Had nothing to do with amy being Sonic's love interest. Just a pure coincidence and insight/ 58.69.7.215 08:40, January 2, 2010 (UTC)Saria the Hedeghog

Actually,she is! Especially look at the second thing in fan theories and the part on Episode 52. Read 'em and weep.

Actually, she is. That official Q&A said exactly that. In fact, while I've even seen a YouTube vid that showed the Q&A page that said so.--Kagi mizu -Seeya  'round ~ 15:07, October 21, 2009 (UTC)


 * Amy, variant of aimée, French, feminine singular past participle of aimer, to love; originally a nickname and also a variant of Latin Amata. As a past participle it technically means "loved" rather than "love", but there you go. Satisfied? -- Supermorff 10:03, October 25, 2009 (UTC)

Amy Stronger than Knuckles in Sonic Chronicles?!
In Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood, Amy is stronger than Knuckles for some reason, i'm starting to think that (at least in that game) her strength increases when she is enraged. --Vae Infectus 02:05, November 23, 2009 (UTC)

It's Been A REALLY Long Time, I Keep On Removing this Nonsense but It KEEPS COMING!
That will happen on wikis. If it's unregistered users that add it back, then I could protect the page so that only registered users can edit. I suspect that the users adding it back are themselves registered, however. -- Supermorff 16:42, January 26, 2010 (UTC)

Is Amy really hated by fans for loving Sonic? I find that hard to believe. Gwen the Mousey! =3  Come play with me!  19:36, July 6, 2010 (UTC)


 * Did you see that in the article? It should definitely be removed. -- Supermorff 19:49, July 6, 2010 (UTC)

Yea, User:Sonamyhater5 put that in. Gwen the Mousey! =3  Come play with me!  19:51, July 6, 2010 (UTC)


 * Right. Well thank you for spotting it and removing it. -- Supermorff 20:35, July 6, 2010 (UTC)

No problem Gwen the Mousey! =3   Come play with me!  21:14, July 6, 2010 (UTC)

Reading all of this made me giggle.

Where are people adding the Taila and Thomas the tank engine from? LOL. I wish I was there...

Ahhh, I don't know about Shadow is "chivalrous" to Amy, but I'm pretty sure the "Shadow respects Amy" came from "what" he said on ARK, not "how many times they talked." What was said was enough to confirm that there's some respect or whatever. You can't acknowledge one thing, such as how many times characters talked, and not acknowledge the other factor there, without being biased, I guess.

And I guess Shadow the Hedgehog (video game) started that "he's chivalrous for her" notion due to the whole "won't earn anything by helping her" stage, but unfortunately this is purely a player's choice option, so it's more like a "producer's point of view of them" rather than a really reliable hint.

It's a hint, but it's improper and indirect. So they're not necessarily delusional for adding that, but for it to be included might be strange.

Personally I think the only person Shadow "mutually respects" to some degree, would be Sonic. It's better and more obvious in Japanese than it is in English Dubs, though.

Everyone else like Amy or Rouge, or Omega, can be categorized as "appreciative towards."

I guess the Amy-thing just took it one step further to people because it was more than a "thank you, I acknowledge that" response from Shadow like he's given to people like Sonic, Rouge, Omega, Blaze (Archie) etc. The "...and you," was like, "I'm including so and so in this."

I'd call it some admiration because of dialogue and gratefulness because of reason behind it, dunno about full out respect just yet...

The "it's because Shadow's nice to girls" sounds more like an excuse to decipher, and not the best one XD; Shadow wasn't nice at all to Rouge in SA2 if calling her a pathetic creature and threatening her life is gentlemanly, and isn't always so nice to her even now. He's impersonally indifferent to everyone's presences unless information or alliance is being exchanged, girls included, but was less indifferent in SA2 to this pink girl here in more than the promise scene occasion (doesn't the profile already say 'spoke non-threateningly, but strangely soft' to pinkie anyway?), even if his smirk and other reaction to the hug isn't a proper back up for that either. So why not leave it open to interpretation since that's what it is? Everyone takes Sonic News Network like it's the Word of God, so I guess being overly opinionated and analytic or technical (what's this foolhardy about Shadow being schizo? Did editors not get the point of the game and that whatever impression it left ended when that same game did?) in the articles should be avoided.

I've personally learned that much.

66.133.206.39 'Jazzy. '

Its probaly because sonetimes they remind him of maria- magnitude99

Some things they have no proof.
Just now, someonne changed amy's age to 13. They did it in 2 places, but forgot to change one which will confuse new sonic fans. If this was true, they shou;d've provided a citation. If not then citation needed should've been put. I think we should protect some of these pages and users can join if they have something useful to say. Pokeboy93 20:04, July 20, 2010 (UTC) Pokeboy93

She's 12, but I don't think it's necessary to block this page, if vandalism keeps up, then we'll might consider it. But I think it's O.k. right now.  Myself 123  20:14, July 20, 2010 (UTC)

I recently heard something about SEGA Forums, an official magazine, and game manual, stating Amy's age has been changed to fourteen. I haven't see any of these links yet, but if I find a citation, should I add it? 66.133.206.39 Jazzy

No, sonic channel still lists it a 12.  Myself  123  01:19, August 15, 2010 (UTC)

Poll confusion
"She is the first female character introduced into the game universe and is also one of the most popular, coming in fourth place on an official popularity poll." If you look on Knuckles' page, it says he is the fourth most popular as well. Or are these different polls? Birdzofafeather 20:33, July 27, 2010 (UTC)


 * Possibly, but that's exactly why references are so important. Very well spotted by the way. -- Supermorff 20:46, July 27, 2010 (UTC)
 * Thank you :-3 I have been known to be pedantic at the best of times Birdzofafeather 11:23, July 28, 2010 (UTC)

Silvamy
I love Silver & Amy! They would be so cute!

I would love to hear anyones opinion about them.

I don't love SilvAmy. SonAmy is alot better.

Knuckleschaotix 15:17, February 1, 2011 (UTC)

I think the same thing. -SonAmygirl 12 26

I dont like copples in general but Silvamy.......... amys like his mom...........

What the heck!? She's younger than he is!

silver shouldn't be with anyone from the past it would ruin the Time-Space continuum and who knows what could happen Ediskrad327 17:21, February 1, 2011 (UTC)

Silver and amy would be a cute couple, but silver is a little too naieve, if he knew amy a lot better they would've been dating on my bet Amyrose1fantem 19:41 October 26, 2011 (ETC)

SilvAmy? Bah! I want to see what EspAmy is like! That would be pretty cool. by the way, I HATE Amy!! Blaze Sol (or Dame Percival)

Undo the last edit, it contains vandalism
Since this page is locked and I am still a "new" user, I can't edit this page but someone please undo the last edit by WavetheSwallow. This person removed some of the links to references and changed Amy's age to 13 instead of 12. Jacktheinfinite101 16:50, August 13, 2010 (UTC)

Thank you for alerting us.  Myself  123  16:58, August 13, 2010 (UTC)

No problem. Thank you for dealing with it so quickly. Jacktheinfinite101 17:02, August 13, 2010 (UTC)

AMY IS A HEDGEHOG!?!?
Amy is a hedgehog!?!? Mesuxelf (talk) 22:09, October 5, 2010 (UTC)

Yes, she always has been.  Myself  123  22:10, October 5, 2010 (UTC)

As scary as it is, SHE IS! (Dun, dun-dun Dun!) Sacorguy79's RPG Level Up is OVER 9001!!!!! 22:12, October 5, 2010 (UTC)Sacorguy79

Well, she's clearly a hedgehog, I mean, she looks like one.

She you can't really say that. She's like the only hedgehog GIRL! None of the hedgehogs look like a hedgehog. KITTENBOMB! What does that mean? 20:45, August 6, 2011 (UTC)

Is she really a hedgehog? In older games she's been called Amy the Rascal... 83.254.125.123 21:24, August 19, 2011 (UTC)


 * Rosy the Rascal was Amy Rose's former name in Sonic CD, her debut title, and Sonic the Fighters, but was changed to her current name in Sonic Adventure and beyond. As for her actual species, several other Uses have already answered that question. Anthromorphic animals in the Sonic series always look different from actual animals, but I'm not seeing you question whether Tails is a fox, or Shadow is a Hedgehog, or if Espio is a chamelleon. Every character's species is mentioned during gameplay in every title they appear in, or is at least mentioned in the game manuals, so I really don't see how you're confused here. Lloyd the Cat  "I hog that hedgehate!"  21:34, August 19, 2011 (UTC)


 * Someone I know actually thought she was a fox! Blaze Sol

Amy's boyfriend is Dexter?
Dexter is not real.Period. 216.240.90.224 21:01, October 21, 2010 (UTC)

Amy "Rosy" Rose The Hedgehog
Amy Rose,The Hedgehog,and her name is originally Rosy. How come her current and Classic name is not listed as the title? 23:48, October 26, 2011 (UTC)

Rosy the Rascal wasn't her classic name and her name is just Amy Rose, no title.  Myself  123  23:50, October 26, 2011 (UTC)

Um.... it's just a nickname.

Amy's Age
I know this is probably a rediculous questions, but since in Sonic Heroes, Amy was 12, and Sonic was 14, shouldn't that technically make her 17-19 now? Just a though, though there probably is no continuity in the Sonic universe, except that Sonic is the only one who ages apparently. And I also think the other characters should have aged as well.184.3.212.254 22:11, November 24, 2011 (UTC)

Characters don't age, and Sonic was 15 in Heroes.  Myself  123  22:15, November 24, 2011 (UTC)

And his birthday in Generations never happened?184.3.215.24 09:04, December 25, 2011 (UTC)

QUOTE: 

"It's my turn now!", Alright which one of you changed her quote to that? Was that allowed, since her other quote, which was her little speech of persuasion, too long of a quote?

I miss it...-Mysterious cat

Quote
QUOTE: 

"It's my turn now!", Alright which one of you changed her quote to that? Was that allowed, since her other quote, which was her little speech of persuasion, too long of a quote?

I miss it...-Mysterious cat

I'm fine with it, I'm not sure about the other admins. -- 21:04, December 6, 2011 (UTC)

I think we need something more memorable, besides her every-second-minute tendencies to scream Sonic's name she has had some pretty good quotes that seems to show her personality better. Definitely change it. Serious  Sam   Heavy 21:14, December 6, 2011 (UTC)Sacorguy79

What?
What happened to Amy's page removed all citations memoralbes good but why not? FlopiSega 00:56, December 13, 2011 (UTC)

Who is faster Amy or Tails or do they share the same speed
Okay I really don't think that's Amy faster cause I'm a Amy fan but beacause I have noticed constanly that she has been faster than him but if anyone doesn't mind a compramise I can make that happen and I wont be agisnt it Sonamyfan666 04:08, February 11, 2012 (UTC)

Let the record reflect that Amy's stats in Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games read that she is faster than Tails. But, let the record also reflect that, according to Tails1, Tails bears a higher speed rating than Amy. Sonamyfan has countered this, saying the most used characters get better stats. However, Amy gets the Dash skill, which is used by the faster characters such as Shadow, and Sonic himself.

Where I stand: It is a toss-up, and this is one of the few cases where a Sonic character's speed in relation to another character's is inconsistent.-- 04:27, February 11, 2012 (UTC)

Amys new voice actor/actress
I dont really like amys new voice in sonic generations wills creed 08:48, March 2, 2012 (UTC)

Yeah, I agree, but I guess we have to survive with it until they change it again. May take 5 years, though. Amindis 23:03, March 4, 2012 (UTC)

none of the new VAs are very good. The boys sound too old, and the girls sound all dainty and helpless.

I agree totaly on this matter and Amy's is by far the worst.Sonamyfan666 11:07, June 21, 2012 (UTC)

I don't know. I thought the LA cast were pretty darn good myself. At the very least, an improvement over the previous cast IMO.

Was iffy about Amy's in particular at first after hearing the voice in 'Riders,' but Cindy Robinson got better for Generations from what I've heard. 67.161.37.97 07:32, June 24, 2012 (UTC)Anon

Rouge the Rival
Why is Rouge listed as an arch-rival? Anyone wanna elaborate? Also, maybe add a section? There was one for Vector, whom she only interacted with once. But why not Rouge, assuming she's an arch-rival?

EDIT: was it just a troll?

They aren't archi-rivals per say, it's just that Rouge loves to anoy Amy and Amy seems to see her as a rival. That's what i get from their interactions anyway. DarkK3 12:59, April 7, 2012 (UTC)

It deserves expanding upon, since she's not mentioned much in the article

brother and sister figures
tails is one of amy's greatest friends that she looks at him as a little brother but i don't know why she only showed this feeling once

Is he? They haven't interacted much.  Myself  123  08:50, April 26, 2012 (UTC)

trust me they do they interact alot in sonic x and amy showed this feeling on the game sonic riders after wave insulted tails and left

Yes but that's Sonic X.  Myself  123  23:29, April 27, 2012 (UTC)

alright yes that's sonic x but there's also that one part on sonic riders

Who hates her?
Just to make it clear, I HATE THIS CHARACTER! She only thinks of herself! It's either her way or hammer! Anyone else agree with this statement? Blaze Sol (or Dame Percival)

In Sonic Free Riders, she cared for her team with the exception of Vector. In the Sonic Advance series, Amy cared for others. She also cared for Sonic. Face it, you're being a Blaze fangirl. Don’t mess with the dubstep. Or you get the claws. 00:01, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

@Cake Does it sound like she is protecting Blaze, NO, does it look like she is praising Blaze, NO, Blaze Sol isn't being a Blaze Fangirl, all she is doing is stating her opinion on Amy. Pacmansonic138 00:53, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

Do you know what a fangirl is? She doesn't need to protect Blaze to be a fangirl. Also, she isn't stating her opinion, it's called being a hater. Don’t mess with the dubstep. Or you get the claws. 01:04, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

Both "hating" and "stating opinion" ARE THE SAME THING. Pacmansonic138 01:09, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

Hating is something that people do to make others feel better. Stating an opinion is something that people do to tell other what they think. Don’t mess with the dubstep. Or you get the claws. 01:11, April 29, 2012 (UTC)

CALM DOWN PEOPLE! I'm just saying my opinion, as Pacmansonic is saying. Blaze Sol

So she's a bit of a Tsundere. She's hardly self-involved. She helps those in need if she's able, which is probably best emphasized in Sonic Adventure. And she does genuinely care for Sonic and the rest of her friends.

I can respect the OP's opinion, but I personally like Amy's character. 67.161.37.97 07:50, June 12, 2012 (UTC)Anon

I can repect ones opionon as well.Sonamyfan666 08:04, June 12, 2012 (UTC)

I repect your opinion, but it's a little unnessesary.Sugar magic 21:42, June 14, 2012 (UTC)

TailsXAmy?
Dude i don't think that his could happen but some of you people might.

I HATE AMY!

Sonally and Sonaze Fan  Forever  18:08, September 7, 2012 (UTC)

Talk pages are talking about the content of the page, not for expressing dis/like for a character.  Myself  123  18:12, September 7, 2012 (UTC)