User blog comment:Stella the skunk/What is your favorite voice cast, and why?/@comment-878100-20120528041043

Sonic Adventure cast was definitely the best; sorry Stella, completely disagree with you. Ryan Drummond played the best Sonic. Jason tried too hard. And at this time they actually used real 8 year old boys, and it made me visual Tails as an actual 8 year old boy; rather than a girl... Knuckles was probably best here too, because he didn't sound like a monster. I think the successing cast made Knuckles sound too much like a monster. Shadow was great then too... but the original voice for him died... right? Eggman's voice has always been played well, but something about the Sonic Adventure era made him sound special. Of course, it could just be nostalgia and the memories. Rouge's voice was rather high for her character, but I think it kept her from sounding too sexual (like she sounds now). I must agree Tails voice wasn't great for Sonic Heroes, but honestly, I don't think any of the voices of him now have done any better.

I think the only thing that was better in the 4kids cast (and therefore the previous cast group before the current one) was Amy's voice. Amy sounded like she was 25 in Sonic Adventure, but she sounded more like she was actually 12 in the 4kids cast.

The current cast isn't bad, but I think that Sonic sounds like he's 33, rather than 15.

Tv show cast was what it was, but I didn't really like it.