Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-6858788-20140603061020/@comment-26808654-20140606000504

A game that focuses on speed (although a bit of parkour is fine). A game where Eggman isn't the main villian. A game where Sonic is put into serious danger that isn't ruined by jokes (jokes are fine so long as they don't kill the mood like Lost World did). A game where the side characters are important to the plot but aren't too important. A game where this new villian is an actual threat and should be taken seriously (and aren't poorly written villians like most of the Deadly Six were). A game with an incredible plot and great music that fits into it (Bonus points if we're allowed to change the stage music like in Generations). A where Big returns for cameo hunts but actually gives you a reward if you find him (such as Secret Rings). A game where the plot has more to it than just "find the Chaos Emeralds to save the world". A game where Rival fights can't be won by spamming the homing attack button. A game with fun multiplayer party mini games (like in secret rings) and non-broken 4-player races.And finally (and I can't stress this enough) '''A game with a Chao Garden! '''(though they better not mess it up. Adventure 2 had an amazing system. Just take that one, improve the graphics, add a bit more content and add it to the game).

That's my perfect game. I'd play it everyday until I die.